Goodwill

2021 S Reynolds Road, Toledo Ohio, 43614

Listing ID: CL-Ohio-28405 Commercial Mixed Use Retail
Published on: Wednesday, September 2, 2026 | Updated on: Wednesday, September 2, 2026

Listing Summary

Prime Toledo, OH retail investment for sale at $1,952,980. Features a corporate Goodwill lease, 7.75% cap rate, 21,712 SF building, and low landlord responsibility.

Full Description

Prime Toledo Retail Investment Property | Corporate Goodwill Guarantee

An exceptional commercial real estate acquisition opportunity is now available in Toledo, Ohio. Priced at $1,952,980, this robust 21,712-square-foot retail asset offers investors an immediate, attractive yield with a 7.75% capitalization rate and approximately $151,000 in net operating income (NOI). Situated on a sprawling 1.92-acre lot, the property provides high visibility, generous parking, and strong real estate fundamentals in a proven Midwest market.

Investment & Property Snapshot

  • Offering Price: $1,952,980

  • Cap Rate: 7.75%

  • Net Operating Income (NOI): ~$151,000

  • Building Size: 21,712 SF

  • Price Per Square Foot: ~$90/SF (Well below replacement cost)

  • Lot Size: 1.92 Acres

  • Year Built: 1972

  • Property Type: Commercial Retail / Street Retail

Key Investment Highlights

  • Corporate Lease Guarantee: Backed by Goodwill, a nationally recognized leader with over 4,000 locations and $7B+ in annual revenue, offering reliable financial backing.

  • Recession-Resilient Asset Class: Needs-based retail model driven by steady donation and value-driven resale traffic, ensuring stability across varying economic cycles.

  • Low-Maintenance NN Lease Structure: Minimal landlord responsibilities, as the tenant handles the majority of operating expenses to deliver hands-off, passive income.

  • Significant Value-Add Potential: Priced well below replacement cost at approximately $90/SF, opening long-term options for repositioning, tenant transition, or strategic redevelopment.

Prime Toledo, OH Location & Demographics Located along a heavily traveled commercial corridor, this property gains maximum street exposure, excellent frontage, and seamless access to major regional thoroughfares. The immediate retail trade area features strong national co-tenants and regional draws, including the nearby Franklin Park Mall, the Toledo Museum of Art, and the Toledo Zoo. Serving a dense surrounding community, the asset benefits from a population of roughly 170,000 residents within a 5-mile radius, supported by steady household income levels and consistent consumer activity.

Quick Glance

  • Listing ID: CL-Ohio-28405
  • Status: Active
  • Year Build: 1972
  • Building Size: 21,712 SqFt
  • Lot Size: 1.92 Acr

Complete Details

  • Year Build: 1972
  • Building Size: 21,712 SqFt
  • No of Stories: 1
  • Total Lot Area: 1.92 Acr
  • No of Parking: 81
  • No of Total Units: 1
  • Heating and Cooling: Not Specified
  • Building Class: Class C
  • Occupancy: 100

Pricing Details

Additional Features

Highlights
  • Attractive Yield: Offered at a 7.75% cap rate with ~$151K NOI, providing strong in-place cash flow
  • Corporate-Backed Tenant: Lease guaranteed by Goodwill, a nationally recognized operator with over 4,000 locations and $7B+ in revenue
  • Recession-Resilient Use: Essential, needs-based retail with consistent traffic driven by donation and resale model
  • Minimal Landlord Responsibilities: NN lease structure with tenant covering majority of expenses, reducing ownership burden
  • Strong Real Estate Fundamentals: 21,712 SF building on 1.92 acres with ample parking and functional layout
  • High Visibility Location: Positioned on a heavily trafficked corridor with excellent frontage and accessibility
  • Value-Add Potential: Below replacement cost (~$90/SF) with future repositioning or redevelopment upside
  • Dense Retail Corridor: Surrounded by national retailers and strong consumer traffic drivers. (see aerials on pages 5–6)
  • Accessible Midwest Market: Located in Toledo with a population of ~170K within 5 miles and solid household incomes
Features
  • Frontage: 170’ on South Reynolds Road
  • Zoning: 10-CR
  • Building FAR: 0.26
  • Tenancy: Single

Listing Location

More Similar Properties

Discover more properties that match your interests

Disclaimer: LoopingCloud is a social listing portal that connects real estate professionals, service providers, buyers, and sellers. All property information, descriptions, availability, financial details, and any offerings are provided by the respective lister or service provider and are not independently verified by LoopingCloud.